The management of stage I lymphomas of the B-cell type with special reference to the role of radiation therapy

Fifty-one patients with clinical stage I B-cell lymphomas were treated between 1980 and 1988. For the entire group, the actuarial 5-year survival rate and 5-year freedom from relapse rate were 78% and 64%, respectively. Primary site, tumor bulk and performance status were the prognostic factors. Twenty-three patients were intensively treated with local radiotherapy alone, because (1) they had histologically low grade (7 patients) or follicular large cell (one patient) tumors, (2) Waldeyer's ring was the site of the primary (11 patients) or (3) the tumor was less than 4 cm in maximum diameter (4 patients). Among them, only one patient died due to lymphoma (5-year survival rate: 95%), and 19 remained disease free (5-year freedom from relapse rate: 80%). In contrast, of the remaining 23 patients treated with both radiation therapy and combination chemotherapy (VEMP or CHOP), the 5-year survival rate and 5-year freedom from relapse rate were 70% and 54%, respectively. These results suggest that high-risk patients should be treated with more aggressive combination chemotherapy as well as radiotherapy. However, low-risk patients with stage I B-cell lymphomas can be treated by local radiotherapy alone. (author)