Volatile element behaviour in cometary ice analogues under irradiation
Description
Comets represent some of the most pristine and unprocessed bodies in our solar system. As such, their analysis can provide a unique insight into the chemical makeup of the early Solar System. Furthermore, due to their volatile-rich nature, comets may have played an important role in delivering volatile elements (e.g., H, C, N, O) and organic materials to the early Earth. Understanding how comets form can therefore provide a wealth of information on how the composition of volatile elements evolved in the solar system, from the pre-solar molecular cloud up until the formation of the terrestrial planets. Decades of cometary studies, and the recent ESA Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/C-G), have demonstrated that volatile species trapped in comets have a composition that is distinct from any other known reservoir in the Solar System. Cometary nitrogen, in particular, shows strong enrichments in the rare 15N isotope. The origin of these enrichments remains unclear, potentially reflecting the isotopic fractionation of an initial 15N-poor nebular gas, or inheritance from an unknown isotopic reservoir. During this PhD, I have developed an experimental setup to form cometary ices (i.e., water-rich ices formed at very low temperatures and pressures), with the overarching objective of exploring how volatile elements (including N and noble gases) were incorporated into cometary ice during water condensation from the protosolar nebula. Different temperatures of formation (from 28 K to 80 K) and irradiation conditions have been tested in order to investigate the conditions that best reproduce the actual volatile composition of comet 67P/C-G. It was found that condensing cometary ice analogues at temperatures ∼70 K is best able to reproduce the nitrogen and noble gas abundances measured in 67P/C-G. Moreover, we discovered that the incorporation of nitrogen and noble gases into, and subsequent release from, cometary ices does not produce significant isotope variations, indicating that isotope signatures in comets were most likely inherited from their environment of formation rather than the result of fractionation during ice formation. Finally, I also investigated the effect that UV irradiation can have on the composition of volatiles trapped within cometary ice. Irradiation during and after ice deposition was found to not have a significant effect on the isotopic composition of the trapped volatile species. However, it was discovered that irradiating the surface of the ice had a major effect on the release pattern of trapped volatiles, with the ice being retentive of trapped volatiles even after the amorphous-to-crystalline ice transition (120-140 K), temperatures at which point all trapped volatiles are released from non-irradiated ice. The enhanced retention of volatiles in irradiated cometary ice may have major implications on the potential for comets to deliver volatile elements to the inner solar system. (author)
Abstract (French)
Les cometes sont parmi les corps les plus primitifs et inalteres de notre systeme solaire. Leur etude peut fournir un apercu unique de la composition chimique du systeme solaire primitif. De plus, en raison de leur nature riche en element volatils, les cometes ont probablement joue un role crucial dans l'apport d'elements pre-biotiques (H, C, N et O) et de matieres organiques a la Terre primitive. Comprendre comment se forment les cometes peut donc fournir une mine d'informations sur l'evolution de la composition des elements volatils dans le systeme solaire, depuis le nuage moleculaire pre-solaire jusqu'a la formation des planetes telluriques. Des decennies d'etudes cometaires, et la recente mission Rosetta de l'ESA sur la comete 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/C-G), ont demontre que les especes volatiles piegees dans les cometes ont une composition distincte de tout autre reservoir connu du systeme solaire. L'azote cometaire, en particulier, presente de forts enrichissements en isotope 15N. L'origine de ces enrichissements reste incertaine, refletant potentiellement la presence de processus permettant de produire de forts fractionnements isotopiques d'un gaz nebulaire initial pauvre en 15N, ou l'heritage d'un reservoir isotopique riche en 15N inconnu. Au cours de cette these, j'ai developpe une experience pour former des glaces cometaires (c'est-a-dire des glaces riches en eau formees a des temperatures et des pressions tres basses), avec l'objectif principal d'explorer comment les elements volatils (l'azote et les gaz nobles) sont incorpores dans les glaces cometaires a partir de la nebuleuse proto-solaire. Differentes temperatures de formation (de 28 K a 80 K) et conditions d'irradiation ont ete testees afin d'etudier les parametres reproduisant le plus fidelement la composition de la comete 67P/C-G. Les analogues de glace cometaires formes experimentalement autour de 70K ont des abondances relatives d'azote et de gaz nobles plus proches de celles mesurees dans 67P/C-G que les analogues formes a plus basses temperatures (≤ 60K). De plus, j'ai mis en evidence que les processus d'incorporation de l'azote et des gaz nobles dans la glace et leur liberation ulterieure ne produisent pas de variations isotopiques significatives. Cela indique que les signatures isotopiques des cometes ont tres probablement ete heritees de leur environnement de formation, et ne resultent pas de processus de fractionnements isotopiques pendant la formation/sublimation de la glace. Enfin, j'ai egalement etudie l'effet que l'irradiation UV peut avoir sur la composition des gaz pieges dans la glace cometaire. L'irradiation pendant et apres le depot de glace n'a que peu d'effet sur la composition isotopique des especes volatiles piegees. Cependant, l'irradiation de la surface de la glace a un effet majeur sur le schema de liberation des gaz pieges. Une glace irradiee conserve ses elements volatils pieges a des temperatures superieures a la temperature de transition de la glace amorphe a cristalline (120-140 K), a l'inverse d'une glace non-irradiee. La retention prolongee des gaz pieges dans les glaces cometaires irradiees peut avoir des implications majeures sur la capacite des cometes a contribuer a l'apport d'elements volatils aux planetes du systeme solaire interne. (auteur)
Files
Additional details
Additional titles
- Original title (English)
- Comportement des elements volatils dans les glaces cometaires irradiees
Publishing Information
- Imprint Pagination
- 204 p.
- Report number
- FRNC-TH--15029
INIS
- Country of Publication
- France
- Country of Input or Organization
- France
- INIS RN
- 54115732
- Subject category
- S75: CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND SUPERFLUIDITY; S36: MATERIALS SCIENCE; S74: ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS;
- Resource subtype / Literary indicator
- Thesis
- Descriptors DEI
- TEMPERATURE DEPENDENCE; TRAPPING; ULTRAVIOLET RADIATION
- Descriptors DEC
- ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION; RADIATIONS
Optional Information
- Notes
- [160 refs.]; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses