Retrospective study on therapy options of brain metastases: surgery versus stereotactic radiotherapy with the linear accelerator

Background: in the therapy of brain metastases there has been a great progress in the last years. It was shown, that more aggressive therapies can not only extend the survival of the patients, but also improve quality of life. The major question of this study was, whether surgery or stereotactic radiotherapy with the linear accelerator show better results in behalf of the survival. Beside this major question many parameters regarding the patient or his primary cancer were examined. Methods: from the 1st of January 1995 until the 30th of June 2000 233 patients with one or more brain metastases have been treated in the Wagner Jauregg Landesnervenkrankenhaus Oberoesterreich (WJ LNKH OeO). The LINAC has been established on the 1st of July 1997. The patients have been distributed in three groups: 1. LINAC-group: 81 patients have been treated from the 1st of July 1997 until the 30th of June 2000 with the LINAC. 2. Surgery-group: 81 patients have been operated from the 1st of July 1997 until the 30th June 2000. 3 Control-group: 71 patients have been operated from the 1st of January 1995 until the 30th of June 1997, before the LINAC has been established on the 1st of July 1997. Results: There are shown the mean survival times. Therapy options (0,05): LINAC-group: 377 days. Surgery-group: 195 days. Control-group: 285 days. Primary cancer (0,05): unknown primary: 203 days. Cancer of the colon tract: 218 days. Breast cancer: 314 days. Melanoma: 162 days. Kidney: 466 days. Lung 261 days. Others: 439 days. Metastases in one/in both hemispheres (0,05): in one hemisphere 310 days, in both 184 days. All the other parameters (age, sex, Karnofsky-Index, period between diagnose of the primary and the brain metastases, primary cancer therapy, extra cerebral metastases, number of metastases, localization of metastases supra- or infratentoriell, dose/effect relationship in the LINAC-group, whole brain radiotherapy) showed interesting differences, but the results were not statistically significant. Conclusion: the therapy with the linear accelerator seems to be a good alternative to surgery. The results show a longer survival in the LINAC-Group. If considered that radiosurgery is less onerous in physical and psychical way and the mean duration of stay in the hospital is only 2 days compared with 13 days in the surgery group, the LINAC therapy is a good procedure for the therapy of brain metastases. That the primary cancer has got effects on the survival of patients is logical. It is shown, that patients who suffer on a type of cancer which has normally got a bad prognoses, have got a shorter survival if they develop brain metastases, than patients with a type of cancer with better prognoses. The survival time gets down if patients have got metastases in both hemispheres. Number is not so important as spread. (author)