Published November 1977 | Version v1
Journal article

Why reprocess

Creators

  • 1. Bundesministerium fuer Forschung und Technologie, Bonn (Germany, F.R.)

Description

The problem of whether to reprocess spent nuclear fuel elements has been studied already in the early days of the commercial utilization of nuclear power and has been answered positively. This also, and in particular, applies to the United States. Under the new American nuclear policy reprocessing is rejected only for reasons of non-proliferation. Although these are valid reasons, the effectiveness of a ban on reprocessing, as fas as the non-profileration of nuclear weapons is concerned, is not accepted worldwide because the necessary knowledge either already exists in many countries or can be obtained. Only if there had been a realistic chance to prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons, also the other industrialized countries would have seconded the policy of the United States. A country like the Federal Republic of Germany, with a substantial long-term nuclear power program based initially on light water reactors, subsequently on advanced reactor systems, cannot do without a complete nuclear fuel cycle. This reasoning is outlined in the light of economic and radioecological aspects. Extensive experience on a technical scale is available in the reprocessing sector. The technical problems associated with this activity have been solved in principle and have largely been demonstrated to function in practice. (orig.)

Abstract (German)

Die Frage, ob abgebrannte Brennelemente wiederaufgearbeitet werden sollen, wurde bereits zu Beginn der kommerziellen Nutzung der Kernenergie untersucht und positiv entschieden. Die Ablehnung der Wiederaufarbeitung im Rahmen der neuen Carterschen Nuklearpolitik geschieht vornehmlich aus Gruenden der Nonproliferation. Die Gruende sind nicht stichhaltig, die Wirksamkeit eines derartigen Verzichts zum heutigen Zeitpunkt wird weltweit verneint. Waere die Moeglichkeit realistisch, wuerden sich auch die anderen Industriestaaten, die ohne Ausnahme einer Weiterverbreitung von Kernwaffen absolut ablehnend gegenueberstehen, dieser Philosophie nicht entziehen koennen, ungeachtet ihrer verlustreichen Folgen. Es gibt jedoch eine Reihe von unwiderlegbaren wirtschaftlichen und radiooekologischen Gruenden, die eine Wiederaufarbeitung fuer alle Kernenergielaender und a la longue auch wieder fuer die USA zwingend notwendig machen. (orig.)

Additional details

Additional titles

Original title (German)
Warum Wiederaufarbeitung

Publishing Information

Journal Title
Atomwirtsch., Atomtech.
Journal Volume
22
Journal Issue
11
Series
Atomwirtsch., Atomtech.
Journal Page Range
566-570

Conference

Title
Reactor congress 1977.
Dates
29 Mar - 1 Apr 1977.
Place
Mannheim, Germany, F.R.

INIS

Country of Publication
Germany
Country of Input or Organization
Germany
INIS RN
9361160
Subject category
S11: NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS;
Resource subtype / Literary indicator
Conference
Descriptors DEI
ECONOMICS; ENERGY POLICY; FUEL CYCLE; NON-PROLIFERATION TREATY; NUCLEAR ENGINEERING; PLANNING; PLUTONIUM RECYCLE; RADIOACTIVE WASTES; REPROCESSING
Descriptors DEC
ENGINEERING; RADIOACTIVE MATERIALS; SEPARATION PROCESSES; TREATIES; WASTES