Evaluation of physiological parameters and their influence on doses calculated from two alternative dosimetric models for the gastrointestinal tract

Two dosimetric models, the catenary compartmental model (Be70) and the slug flow model (Sk75), are examined using three sets of physiological parameters: those proposed by Eve, those proposed by ICRP, and those obtained from the Textbook of Physiology and Biochemistry by Bell et al. The impact of physiological parameters on the dosimetry of the tract is illustrated by comparing calculated maximum permissible daily activity ingestion rates for single, unabsorbed, particle emitting radionuclides with an effective energy term of unity. The conclusions drawn from this intercomparison of six different cases are: Current dosimetric models which use physiological parameters described in this article do not significantly disagree, and for the determination of average dose equivalent rates to segments of the tract due to chronic, long term ingestion of any radionuclide, the catenary compartmental model is a mathematically simpler approach. The catenary model in addition has certain advantages for the calculation of the photon dose contribution to one segment from cumulated activity (disintegrations) in another segment