Engineering design evaluation of Atlas tile-calorimeter

In an effort to familiarize themselves with the work that has been done to date on the design of the Tile Cal hadron calorimeter for Atlas, the authors have undertaken a thorough examination of the current designs. They concentrated on the work that has been done by the IHEP Group at Protvino, and in particular the work presented at the last Atlas Week. They constructed six different finite element models as they have learned more about the system. These models were meant to be rough models only and do not represent actual construction in all cases. In some cases, shortcuts were taken in an attempt to set boundary conditions and to reduce the size of the problem to accommodate software limitations, while still providing enough information to further the understanding of the design. After reviewing the analysis and thinking about the construction, the authors have some suggested modifications, which are presented in this paper. It is clear that the work done at both CERN and Protvino has been impressive and thorough. The authors have tried to evaluate and understand both the CERN baseline design and the suggested design option from Protvino