Tracking the dispersion of contaminated sediments in Fukushima coastal catchments
Description
Large quantities of radionuclides were released into the atmosphere by the Fukushima Dai-Ichi Nuclear Power Plant (FDNPP) after the earthquake-triggered tsunami devastated the eastern coast of Japan on March 11, 2011. Many of these radionuclides (20%) were deposited on soils of the Fukushima Prefecture. This PhD thesis develops original fingerprinting methods to track the dispersion of contaminated particles following this accident. The study focuses on 3 coastal catchments north of the FDNPP (Mano - 175 km2, Niida - 270 km2 and Ota - 75 km2) draining heavily contaminated areas of the radioactive plume. The Fukushima Prefecture is characterized by an erosive climate, with the occurrence of spring floods and summer typhoons. To study the dispersion of the radioactive contamination, soil samples and sediment drape deposits were collected during 6 sampling campaigns (every six months between November 2011 and May 2014; i.e., after the major flood events). Each sample was analyzed by gamma spectrometry to determine radionuclide activities, and several soil and sediment samples were also analyzed by neutron activation analysis to determine their geochemistry. First, the analysis of 137Cs activity in 10 soil cores collected in paddy fields confirmed the limited migration of radiocesium with depth in the soils of the coastal catchments. More than 90% of the contamination was still concentrated in the uppermost 2 cm of the soils by November 2013. Particles contaminated were therefore available for mobilization and transport downstream by processes that govern soil erosion. Second, metastable silver-110 (110mAg) was detected in most of the samples collected between November 2011 and November 2012, and our investigation showed that this radionuclide has a similar behavior as 137Cs in soil and sediment. Consequently, we used 110mAg to track the dispersion of the contamination as the 110mAg/137Cs activity ratio in soils of the Niida catchment showed significant differences between upstream and downstream locations. The use of a binary mixing model allowed the identification of a seasonal cycle of erosion and dispersion of particles. However, as 110mAg has a short half-life (250 days), it rapidly decayed and could not be detected anymore by May 2013. To overcome its disappearance, the contribution of soils located on the mountainous plateaus to the sediment transiting the river in the coastal plains was quantified based on their 137Cs signature. Binary mixing models were used, based on the distributions of 137Cs in mountainous areas (≥ 20 kBq/m2) and in coastal plains (≤ 20 kBq/m2). The results demonstrated that the contribution of the mountainous area varied in the different catchments. In the Niida catchment where no dam has been built, the mountainous area supplies more sediment to the river (≅46%) than in the Mano catchment that has a dam (≅20%). These results show the impact of dams generating a sediment dis-connectivity. Finally, the soil map of the region was used in order to identify the soil types that may supply sediment to the rivers. The main soil types (Andosols, Cambisols and Fluvisols) were characterized by their geochemical composition, and Sc and Yb were identified as the most discriminant elements. The distributions of these elements in the three sources were used in a mixing model. Results show that Fluvisols are the main source supplying ≥70% of sediment to the rivers in both catchments. This soil type is mainly found in paddy fields, which confirms the enhanced erodibility of these cultivated areas. In the future, the dataset compiled could be used to improve soil erosion model operating at the catchment scale. Moreover, the impact of the ongoing decontamination works on the dispersion of contaminated sediments should be investigated. (author)
Abstract (French)
Suite aux seismes et au tsunami qui ont frappe les cotes japonaises le 11 mars 2011, d'importantes quantites de radionucleides ont ete emises par la centrale de Fukushima Dai-Ichi. Une part non negligeable (20%) du radiocesium rejete s'est ensuite deposee sur les sols de la Prefecture de Fukushima. Cette etude vise a developper des methodes de tracage sedimentaire originales afin de comprendre la dispersion des particules contaminees. L'etude se concentre sur 3 bassins versants cotiers situes au nord de la centrale (bassins de la Mano - 175 km2, Niida - 270 km2 et Ota - 75 km2) et drainant la partie la plus contaminee du panache de pollution radioactive. Cette region connait un climat particulierement erosif, avec des crues printanieres et le passage de typhons entre juin et octobre. Pour etudier la dispersion de la contamination radioactive initiale, des sols et des laisses de crues ont ete collectes au cours de 6 campagnes de terrain (organisees tous les 6 mois entre novembre 2011 et mai 2014 apres les crues printanieres et les typhons estivaux). L'activite des principaux radionucleides a ete mesuree par spectrometrie gamma et une selection d'echantillons a egalement ete analysee par activation neutronique afin de determiner leur teneur en une vingtaine d'elements. L'analyse de l'activite en 137Cs dans 10 carottes de sols collectees dans des rizieres a confirme la faible migration du cesium en profondeur dans les sols de la region. Plus de 90 % de la contamination etaient concentres dans les 2 cm superficiels des sols en novembre 2013. Cette contamination situee a la surface du sol reste donc potentiellement mobilisable par l'erosion. Par ailleurs, la detection d'argent-110 metastable (110mAg) et le fait que ce radioisotope ait un comportement similaire a celui du cesium, ont permis de l'utiliser pour tracer la dispersion de la contamination dans le bassin versant de la Niida. En effet, le rapport d'activites 110mAg/137Cs dans les sols de ce bassin est significativement different a l'amont et a l'aval de celui-ci. L'utilisation de ce rapport et d'un modele de melange binaire a permis d'identifier l'occurrence de cycles d'erosion et de dispersion saisonniers de la contamination. Cependant, 110mAg ayant une demi-vie de 250 jours, il a rapidement decru et l'activite est devenue inferieure aux limites de detection a compter de mai 2013. Pour pallier sa disparition, la contribution des sols des plateaux montagneux aux sediments transitant dans la plaine cotiere a ete quantifiee a partir de leur signature en 137Cs. En utilisant un modele de melange binaire base sur les distributions du 137Cs a l'amont (≥ 20 kBq/m2) et a l'aval (≤ 20 kBq/m2) des bassins versants, les resultats montrent que la contribution de la zone amont differe en fonction du bassin versant. Elle fournit une part non negligeable (≅46%) des sediments a la riviere Niida, qui est depourvue de barrage, a la difference de la riviere Mano (≅20 %) qui en est equipee. Ces resultats montrent donc l'impact de ce type d'ouvrage qui genere une dysconnectivite sedimentaire. Afin de preciser l'origine spatiale des sediments contamines transportes par ces rivieres, la carte des sols des bassins versants a ete utilisee. Les principaux types de sols (Andosols, Cambisols et Fluvisols) ont ete caracterises par leurs teneurs en elements chimiques, et Sc et Yb se sont reveles etre le couple d'elements le plus discriminant. Les distributions de ces deux elements dans les trois sources ont ensuite ete utilisees dans un modele de melange. Les resultats montrent une contribution majoritaire (≥ 70 %) des Fluvisols dans les sediments. La forte contribution de ce type de sol, que l'on trouve principalement dans les rizieres, confirme donc l'erodabilite accrue de ces zones agricoles. Pour poursuivre ces travaux, l'ensemble des donnees acquises pourrait etre utilise pour ameliorer les modeles d'erosion des sols operant a l'echelle des bassins versants. (l'auteur)
Files
Additional details
Additional titles
- Original title (French)
- Tracage de la dispersion des sediments contamines dans les bassins versants cotiers de Fukushima
Publishing Information
- Imprint Pagination
- 302 p.
- Report number
- FRCEA-TH--10224
INIS
- Country of Publication
- France
- Country of Input or Organization
- France
- INIS RN
- 50020471
- Subject category
- S21: SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS; S54: ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES;
- Resource subtype / Literary indicator
- Thesis
- Descriptors DEI
- ACCIDENTS; CESIUM 137; CONTAMINATION; EROSION; FUKUSHIMA DAIICHI NUCLEAR POWER STATION; GAMMA SPECTROSCOPY; GEOCHEMISTRY; RADIOACTIVITY; SEDIMENTS; SILVER 110; SOILS
- Descriptors DEC
- BETA DECAY RADIOISOTOPES; BETA-MINUS DECAY RADIOISOTOPES; CESIUM ISOTOPES; CHEMISTRY; DAYS LIVING RADIOISOTOPES; ELECTRON CAPTURE RADIOISOTOPES; INTERMEDIATE MASS NUCLEI; ISOMERIC TRANSITION ISOTOPES; ISOTOPES; NUCLEI; ODD-EVEN NUCLEI; ODD-ODD NUCLEI; RADIOISOTOPES; REACTOR SITES; SECONDS LIVING RADIOISOTOPES; SILVER ISOTOPES; SPECTROSCOPY; YEARS LIVING RADIOISOTOPES
Optional Information
- Notes
- 484 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses; Also available from le service commun de la documentation de l'universite Paris-Sud, Bat 407 - 91405 Orsay Cedex (France)