Optical emission from cooling flows in distant x ray clusters of galaxies

Although the Einstein satellite detected cooling flows in the x ray emission from clusters of galaxies 10 years ago, the understanding of these flows remains incomplete. The x ray emitting gas in the centers of these clusters is so dense that its cooling time is shorter than a Hubble time. Thus gas may cool and flow into the center of the cluster. This cooling gas is thermally unstable and should quickly become inhomogeneous. Optical filamentation (1-100 kpc scales) often appears near the centers of nearby clusters containing cooling flows, usually within the central galaxies accreting the gas. Indeed, only clusters with well-developed cooling flows seem to possess highly luminous, emission-line nebulae. Researchers present here some results of preliminary observational and theoretical studies of this class of emission-line objects. Researchers observed a complete, x ray selected sample of 25 distant clusters of galaxies extracted from the Einstein Extended Medium Sensitivity Survey. They discovered luminous extended H alpha emission in 10 of these clusters. Thus at least 40 percent of the clusters in the sample contain cool gas. If we crudely compare the sample to that of Arnaud (1988), in which approx. 40 percent of his 104 x ray clusters have cooling flows, the result implies that cooling flows may actually be a more common phenomenon in the past than in the present. The connection between the cooling flow and the H alpha emission is a mystery. The straightforward calculation of 1 (photoionization) to 3 (shocks) recombinations per H atom in the cooling flow gives mass infall rates 3 to 100 times greater than M derived from x ray observations. Researchers have made some preliminary theoretical calculations in an attempt to resolve this problem