Optimal adiabatic passage by shaped pulses: Efficiency and robustness

We explore the efficiency and robustness of population transfer in two-state systems by adiabatic passage (i) when the driving pulse is optimally designed in order to lead to parallel adiabatic passage or (ii) with a linear chirping. We show how one could practically implement the corresponding designs of the pulses in the spectral domain. We analyze the robustness of the two shapings taking into account fluctuations of the phase, amplitude, and the area of the pulse. We show the overall superiority of the parallel adiabatic passage especially when one faces the issue of a pulse area that is not well known. We show that the robustness of parallel adiabatic passage is not improved when it is complemented by a correcting field that cancels out the nonadiabatic losses.