The Bose metal : a commentary

We review the concept of the Bose metal state which arises in 2D superconductors in the quantum limit where vortex loops can grow spontaneously in (2+1) dimensions and, as zero point motions become larger, eventually lead to an insulating state. A nonlocal Coulomb charging term in a Josephson array type model leads to an effective transverse gauge field which can suppress the condensate of vortices in the superinsulating state leading to an intermediate Bose liquid which is not superfluid at T=0, the Bose metal state. We comment on recent work on this state and on other non-superfluid Bose liquids. (author)