Matrix-based autologous chondrocyte implantation for cartilage repair with Hyalograft(R)C: Two-year follow-up by magnetic resonance imaging

Objective: Monitoring of articular cartilage repair after matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte implantation with Hyalograft(R)C by a new grading system based on non-invasive high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging. Patients and methods: In 23 patients, postoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed between 76 and 120 weeks. In nine of these patients, five MRI examinations were performed at 4, 12, 24, 52 and 104 weeks after Hyalograft(R)C implant. The repair tissue was described with separate variables: degree of defect repair in width and length, signal intensity of the repair tissue and status of the subchondral bone. For these variables a grading system with point scale evaluation was applied. Results: A complete filling of the defect by repair tissue was found in 15 patients. A moderate hypertrophy of the repair tissue was found in two patients. An underfilling of the defect by repair tissue was observed in four patients. In one patient, a partial detachment of the implant with associated subchondral cyst and edema was seen, and in one patient, a complete detachment of the graft was observed. The filling of the defect parallel to cartilage surface (integration) was complete in 18 cases. A split-like incomplete integration was present in one patient. Incomplete integration was found in four patients. The signal intensity of the implant on FSE and on 3D-GRE+FS was isointense compared to native normal cartilage in all cases after 12 months. The subchondral bone was normal in 14 patients. An edema-like signal alteration was found in three cases. In six patients, a non-edema abnormality of the subchondral bone (granulation tissue, cysts or sclerosis) was present. On follow-up exams performed in nine patients at the same postoperative intervals dynamic processes such as filling of partial defects, vanishing of hypertrophies and change of signal intensity of implant to isointensity with native articular cartilage were observed. A comparison between filling of the defect on MRI and clinical outcome showed a good correlation in 21 patients and a poor correlation in only two patients. Conclusion: High-resolution MRI provides a non-invasive tool for monitoring the development of cartilage repair tissue following Hyalograft(R)C technology, shows a good correlation with clinical outcome and may help to differentiate abnormal repair tissue from a normal maturation process. ss