Published October 19, 2018 | Version v1
Miscellaneous Restricted

Adaptation of the hybrid Eulerian/Lagrangian stochastic model of the CFD code Code-Saturne to pollutant atmospheric dispersion at the micro-meteorological scale and comparison with the Eulerian method

Description

This Ph.D. thesis is part of a project that aims at modeling pollutant atmospheric dispersion with the Computational Fluid Dynamics code Code-Saturne. The objective is to simulate atmospheric dispersion of pollutants in a complex environment, that is to say around power plants, industrial sites or in urban areas. In this context, the focus is on modeling the dispersion at micro-scale, that is for distances of the order of a few meters to a few kilometers and corresponding to time scales of the order of a few tens of seconds to a few tens of minutes: this is also called the near field area. The approach followed in this thesis follows a hybrid Eulerian/Lagrangian formulation, where the mean dynamical fields relative to the carrier fluid (pressure, velocity, temperature, turbulence) are calculated through an Eulerian approach and are then provided to the Lagrangian solver. This type of formulation is commonly used in the atmospheric literature for its numerical efficiency. The Lagrangian stochastic model considered in our work is the Simplified Langevin Model (SLM), developed by Pope (1985, 2000). This model belongs to the methods commonly referred to as PDF (Probability Density Function) methods, and, to our knowledge, has not been used before in the context of atmospheric dispersion. First, we show that the SLM meets the so-called well-mixed criterion (Thomson, 1987). This criterion, essential for any Lagrangian stochastic model to be regarded as acceptable, corresponds to the fact that if particles are initially uniformly distributed in an incompressible fluid, then they must remain so. We check the good respect of the well-mixed criterion for three cases of inhomogeneous turbulence representative of a wide range of practical applications: a mixing layer, an infinite plane channel, and an atmospheric-like case involving an obstacle within a neutral boundary layer. We show that the good respect of the well-mixed criterion lies simply in the good introduction of the pressure gradient term as the mean drift term in the Langevin model (Pope, 1987; Minier et al., 2014; Bahlali et al., 2018c). Also, we discuss the importance of consistency between Eulerian and Lagrangian fields in the framework of such Eulerian/Lagrangian hybrid formulations. Then, we validate the model in the case of continuous point source pollutant dispersion, under uniform wind and homogeneous turbulence. In these conditions, there is an analytical solution allowing a precise verification. We observe that in this case, the Lagrangian model discriminates well the two different near- and far-field diffusion regimes, which is not the case for an Eulerian model based on the eddy-viscosity hypothesis (Bahlali et al., 2018b). Finally, we work on the validation of the model on several experimental campaigns in real atmosphere, taking into account atmospheric thermal stratification and the presence of buildings. The first experimental program considered in our work has been conducted on the 'SIRTA' site (Site Instrumental de Recherche par Teledetection Atmospherique), in the southern suburb of Paris, and involves a stably stratified surface layer. The second campaign studied is the MUST (Mock Urban Setting Test) experiment. Conducted in the United States, in Utah's desert, this experiment aims at representing an idealized city, through several ranges of containers. Two cases are simulated and analyzed, respectively corresponding to neutral and stable atmospheric stratifications (Bahlali et al., 2018a). (author)

Abstract (French)

Cette these s'inscrit dans un projet de modelisation numerique de la dispersion atmospherique de polluants a travers le code de mecanique des fluides numerique Code-Saturne. L'objectif est de pouvoir simuler la dispersion atmospherique de polluants en environnement complexe, c'est-a-dire autour de centrales, sites industriels ou en milieu urbain. Dans ce contexte, nous nous concentrons sur la modelisation de la dispersion des polluants a micro-echelle, c'est-a-dire pour des distances de l'ordre de quelques metres a quelques kilometres et correspondant a des echelles de temps de l'ordre de quelques dizaines de secondes a quelques dizaines de minutes: on parle de modelisation en champ proche. L'approche suivie dans ces travaux de recherche suit une formulation hybride eulerienne/ lagrangienne, ou les champs dynamiques moyens relatifs au fluide porteur (pression, vitesse, temperature, turbulence) sont calcules via une approche eulerienne et sont ensuite fournis au solveur lagrangien. Ce type de formulation est couramment utilise dans la litterature atmospherique pour son efficacite numerique. Le modele lagrangien stochastique considere dans nos travaux est le Simplified Langevin Model (SLM), developpe par Pope (1985, 2000). Ce modele appartient aux methodes communement appelees methodes PDF (Probability Density Function), et, a notre connaissance, n'a pas ete exploite auparavant dans le contexte de la dispersion atmospherique. Premierement, nous montrons que le SLM respecte le critere dit de melange homogene (Thomson, 1987). Ce critere, essentiel pour juger de la bonne qualite d'un modele lagrangien stochastique, correspond au fait que si des particules sont initialement uniformement reparties dans un fluide incompressible, alors elles doivent le rester. Nous verifions le bon respect du critere de melange homogene pour trois cas de turbulence inhomogene representatifs d'une large gamme d'applications pratiques: une couche de melange, un canal plan infini, ainsi qu'un cas de type atmospherique mettant en jeu un obstacle au sein d'une couche limite neutre. Nous montrons que le bon respect du critere de melange homogene reside simplement en la bonne introduction du terme de gradient de pression en tant que terme de derive moyen dans le modele de Langevin (Pope, 1987; Minier et al., 2014; Bahlali et al., 2018c). Nous discutons parallelement de l'importance de la consistance entre champs euleriens et lagrangiens dans le cadre de telles formulations hybrides euleriennes/lagrangiennes. Ensuite, nous validons le modele dans le cas d'un rejet de polluant ponctuel et continu, en conditions de vent uniforme et turbulence homogene. Dans ces conditions, nous disposons en effet d'une solution analytique nous permettant une verification precise. Nous observons que dans ce cas, le modele lagrangien discrimine bien les deux differents regimes de diffusion de champ proche et champ lointain, ce qui n'est pas le cas d'un modele eulerien a viscosite turbulente (Bahlali et al., 2018b). Enfin, nous travaillons sur la validation du modele sur plusieurs campagnes experimentales en atmosphere reelle, en tenant compte de la stratification thermique de l'atmosphere et de la presence de batiments. Le premier programme experimental considere dans nos travaux concerne le site du SIRTA (Site Instrumental de Recherche par Teledetection Atmospherique), dans la banlieue sud de Paris, et met en jeu une stratification stable de la couche limite atmospherique. La seconde campagne etudiee est l'experience MUST (Mock Urban Setting Test). Realisee aux Etats-Unis, dans le desert de l'Utah, cette experience a pour but de representer une ville idealisee, au travers d'un ensemble de lignees de conteneurs. Deux rejets ont ete simules et analyses, respectivement en conditions d'atmosphere neutre et stable (Bahlali et al., 2018a). (auteur)

Files

Restricted

The record is publicly accessible, but files are restricted to users with access.

Additional details

Additional titles

Original title (French)
Adaptation de la modelisation hybride eulerienne/lagrangienne stochastique de Code-Saturne a la dispersion atmospherique de polluants a l'echelle micro-meteorologique et comparaison a la methode eulerienne

Publishing Information

Imprint Pagination
251 p.
Report number
FRNC-TH--14180

Optional Information

Notes
128 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses