Published December 14, 2011 | Version v1
Miscellaneous Open

Uncertainty estimation and risk prediction in air quality

Description

This work is about uncertainty estimation and risk prediction in air quality. Firstly, we build a multi-model ensemble of air quality simulations which can take into account all uncertainty sources related to air quality modeling. Ensembles of photochemical simulations at continental and regional scales are automatically generated. Then, these ensemble are calibrated with a combinatorial optimization method. It selects a sub-ensemble which is representative of uncertainty or shows good resolution and reliability for probabilistic forecasting. This work shows that it is possible to estimate and forecast uncertainty fields related to ozone and nitrogen dioxide concentrations or to improve the reliability of threshold exceedance predictions. The approach is compared with Monte Carlo simulations, calibrated or not. The Monte Carlo approach appears to be less representative of the uncertainties than the multi-model approach. Finally, we quantify the observational error, the representativeness error and the modeling errors. The work is applied to the impact of thermal power plants, in order to quantify the uncertainty on the impact estimates. (author)

Abstract (French)

Ce travail porte sur l'estimation des incertitudes et la prevision de risques en qualite de l'air. Il consiste dans un premier temps a construire un ensemble de simulations de la qualite de l'air qui prend en compte toutes les incertitudes liees a la modelisation. Des ensembles de simulations a l'echelle continentale ou regionale sont generes automatiquement. Ensuite, les ensembles generes sont calibres par une methode d'optimisation combinatoire qui selectionne un sous-ensemble representatif de l'incertitude ou performant (fiabilite et resolution) pour des previsions probabilistes. Ainsi, il est possible d'estimer et de prevoir des champs d'incertitude sur les concentrations d'ozone ou de dioxyde d'azote, ou encore d'ameliorer la fiabilite des previsions e depassement de seuil. Cette approche est ensuite comparee avec la calibration d'un ensemble Monte Carlo. Ce dernier, moins disperse, est moins representatif de l'incertitude. Enfin, on a pu estimer la part des erreurs de mesure, de representativite et de modelisation de la qualite de l'air. Ces travaux ont ete appliques a l'impact de centrales thermiques, afin de quantifier l'incertitude sur les impacts estimes. (auteur)

Files

49009566.pdf

Files (14.5 MB)

Name Size Download all
md5:fe4141a0b45bae0a23490e5e77296889
14.5 MB Preview Download

Additional details

Additional titles

Original title (French)
Estimation des incertitudes et prevision des risques en qualite de l'air

Publishing Information

Imprint Pagination
201 p.
Report number
FRNC-TH--9932

Optional Information

Notes
99 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the 'INIS contacts' section of the INIS web site for current contact and E-mail addresses: http://www.iaea.org/inis/Contacts/