Corrosion mechanisms understanding in the environment of future reactors using molten salt fuel and coolant
Description
For the past decade, an increasing interest have been showed to molten chloride salts in the field of energy production and storage. Their physico-chemical properties, associated with the development of liquid-fuelled fourth-generation nuclear reactors, may be relied on to design efficient systems in terms of resource sustainability, actinide waste elimination and safety. The Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) program on the molten salt reactor experiment led to the development of the Hastelloy N alloy, a nickel alloy containing 7 wt% of Cr and 16 wt% of Mo. The composition of the alloy was optimized for corrosion resistance (both in low oxygen gas atmosphere and in molten fluorides), irradiation resistance and high temperature mechanical properties. Nevertheless, no notably resistant materials in molten chlorides have been identified and optimized so far, due to a less advanced research around nuclear systems exploiting chloride-based fuel salt. The main studies conducted in these environments have revealed the complexity of the corrosion mechanisms of materials in contact with molten chloride salts, which is due to the interaction between the dissolved species in the salt and the immersed materials, but also the interaction between atmospheric gases and the melted salt. The oxide ions activity (oxo-acidity) in the salt is, for example, one of the key parameters regarding the behavior of materials in molten chloride salts. However, the determination of the oxo-acidity is not frequently addressed among corrosion studies in molten chloride salt media.In the first part of the present study, various electrochemical techniques in molten salts were exploited and compared in order to quantify in the best way the oxo-acidity of the NaCl-CaCl2 binary salt molten at 600 C. The obtained results demonstrated the good complementarity between the two main techniques for in-situ quantification of oxide ions in molten salts which are cyclic voltammetry and the yttria zirconia probe. Their use subsequently made it possible to monitor the enrichment in oxide ions of the NaCl-CaCl2 mixture, by addition of CaO, as well as their depletion by separate addition of MgCl2 and ZrCl4. Obtaining these different oxo-acidity conditions allowed to set the conditions for the immersion tests aimed at better understanding the impact of the oxide ion content on the corrosion of the immersed materials. The three selected test materials for the immersions are the 304 stainless steel, the nickel-based C276 alloy, and the ceramic Cr2AlC. The corroded samples are characterized by gravimetric measurements, as well as by SEM-EDS observations and XRD analyses. The results obtained after static immersion for 336 h in NaCl-CaCl2 at 600 C demonstrated that the corrosion resistance of the materials considered increased in the order: SS304 < C276 < Cr2AlC, but also that the corrosion mechanisms for the two alloys differed according to the oxo-acidity and the presence of reactive element in the salt. The Cr2AlC ceramic behavior differs from the two alloys, by presenting a corrosion mechanism that is not significantly disturbed by the oxo-acidity conditions, however the corrosion kinetics of the Cr2AlC depend on the oxo-acidity conditions. A third part was dedicated to the impact of the oxidizing species contained in the sweep gas, on the corrosion of the nickel-based alloy C276 immersed in the liquid salt NaCl-CaCl2. These immersion studies, associated with gas chromatography analyses, revealed the role of O2 and H2O on the corrosion of the C276 alloy. These results, brought together with those concerning the influence of oxo-acidity, have made it possible to outline a global mechanism of corrosion in NaCl-CaCl2 at 600 C. (author)
Abstract (French)
Depuis plusieurs annees, l'etude des sels chlorures fondus s'est amplifiee dans le domaine de la production et du stockage energetique. Leurs proprietes physico-chimiques, associees au developpement de reacteurs nucleaires de quatrieme generation a combustible liquide, permettraient de concevoir des systemes plus performants en termes de securite intrinseque, de durabilite des ressources et d'elimination des dechets d'actinides. Le programme de recherche du laboratoire national d'Oak Ridge (ORNL) sur le MSRE (Molten salt Reactor Experiment) a conduit au developpement de l'alliage Hastelloy N, un alliage a base de nickel contenant 7 mass.% de Cr et 16 mass.% de Mo. La composition de cet alliage fut optimisee pour une meilleure resistance a la corrosion (a la fois dans une atmosphere d'oxygene et dans les fluorures fondus), a l'irradiation et pour ses proprietes mecaniques a haute temperature. Neanmoins, aucun materiau specifiquement resistant dans les chlorures fondus n'a ete identifie ni optimise jusqu'a present, en raison d'une recherche anterieure moins avancee autour des systemes nucleaires exploitant ce type de sel. Les principales etudes menees dans ces milieux ont revele la complexite des mecanismes de corrosion, qui impliquent l'interaction entre les especes dissoutes dans le sel et les materiaux immerges mais egalement l'interaction entre le ciel gazeux et le sel fondu. La teneur en ions oxyde (oxoacidite) dans le sel est, par exemple, un des parametres cles vis-a-vis de la tenue des materiaux en sels chlorures fondus. La determination et le suivi de l'oxoacidite du sel n'est pourtant que tres peu realisee dans les etudes de corrosion en milieux sels fondus chlorures. La premiere partie des travaux presente les diverses techniques electrochimiques en sels fondus qui ont ete exploitees et comparees afin de pouvoir quantifier l'oxoacidite du sel binaire NaCl-CaCl2 fondu a 600 C. Les resultats obtenus montrent la bonne complementarite entre les deux principales techniques de quantification in-situ des ions oxydes en sels fondus, a savoir la voltammetrie cyclique et la sonde de zircone yttriee. Leur utilisation a par la suite permis de suivre l'enrichissement en ions oxyde du melange NaCl-CaCl2, par ajout de CaO, ainsi que son appauvrissement par ajouts de MgCl2 ou ZrCl4. L'obtention de ces differentes conditions d'oxoacidite a permis de fixer les conditions des essais d'immersion visant a comprendre l'impact de la teneur en ions oxyde sur la corrosion des materiaux immerges. Les trois materiaux d'etude retenus pour les immersions menees sont l'acier inoxydable 304, l'alliage C276 a base de nickel et la ceramique Cr2AlC. Les echantillons ont ete caracterises par mesures gravimetriques ainsi que par observations MEB-EDS et analyses DRX. Les resultats obtenus apres immersions statiques de 336 h dans NaCl-CaCl2 a 600 C ont mis en evidence d'une part que la resistance a la corrosion des materiaux etudies augmente dans l'ordre: 304 < C276 < Cr2AlC, et d'autre part que les mecanismes de corrosion pour les deux alliages varient selon l'oxoacidite et la presence d'element reactif dans le sel. La phase Cr2AlC se distingue des deux alliages, en presentant un mecanisme de corrosion independant des conditions d'oxoacidite mais dont la vitesse de corrosion en depend. Une troisieme partie est consacree a l'impact des especes oxydantes contenues dans le gaz de balayage, sur la corrosion de l'alliage a base de nickel C276 immerge dans le sel liquide NaCl-CaCl2. Ces etudes d'immersion, associees a des analyses par chromatographie gazeuse ont revele le role de O2 et H2O sur la corrosion de l'alliage C276. Ces resultats, associes a ceux concernant l'influence de l'oxoacidite ont permis de proposer un mecanisme global de corrosion des materiaux dans NaCl-CaCl2 a 600 C
Files
Additional details
Additional titles
- Original title (French)
- Comprehension des mecanismes de corrosion en environnement reacteurs du futur a combustible et caloporteur sels fondus
Publishing Information
- Imprint Pagination
- 218 p.
- Report number
- FRCEA-TH--16453
INIS
- Country of Publication
- France
- Country of Input or Organization
- France
- INIS RN
- 54123604
- Subject category
- S36: MATERIALS SCIENCE;
- Resource subtype / Literary indicator
- Thesis
- Descriptors DEI
- CHLORIDES; CORROSION RESISTANCE; ELECTROCHEMISTRY; MATERIALS; MOLTEN SALTS; NICKEL BASE ALLOYS; REACTORS
- Descriptors DEC
- ALLOYS; CHEMISTRY; CHLORINE COMPOUNDS; HALIDES; HALOGEN COMPOUNDS; NICKEL ALLOYS; SALTS; TRANSITION ELEMENT ALLOYS
Optional Information
- Notes
- 137 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses