Published March 5, 2021 | Version v1
Report Restricted

Analysis and modeling of the impacts of the development of intermittent renewable energies on the French electricity system: Study of the potential of electricity storage and the complementarity with heat

Description

France aims to massively develop intermittent renewable energies - wind and photovoltaic - while reducing the share of dispatchable sources, in this case, nuclear power. This paradigm shift implies rethinking the management of energy systems. Indeed, renewables' variable nature generates a need for flexibility on different time-scales, from day to year. As dispatchable means' flexibility can no longer be relied on, this thesis questions the potential of other means to meet this need: electricity storage, oversized production and heating networks.Faced with the need for a systemic approach, we developed simple models to enhance the understanding of the interdependencies between production and storage. The optimized indicators are economic (...), but also environmental: embodied energy and greenhouse gas emissions over the entire life cycle. The performances of the systems considered are those of today and their development is limited by resource and space availability. Without going into the precise details of how each technology works, this physical approach points out optimal operation areas for the different technologies and the difficult cases for which solutions are still lacking.First, the need for flexibility generated for different intermittency penetration rates is quantified for several time scales. It enables us to compare the potential of different electricity storage technologies - at each of these scales - to bring production and consumption in phase. The results show that long time-scales - typically seasonal storage - require the largest investments for low profitability. The competition mechanisms between several storages and over sizing are then analyzed. It shows how the optimum solutions use complementary flexibility means. The study then addresses the potential of coupling between the electrical grid and the heating grid as a means of flexibility, particularly for the management of long-term needs.This thesis work focuses on the French scale, although the methodology is applicable elsewhere. (author)

Abstract (French)

La France affiche une volonte de developper massivement les energies renouvelables intermittentes - eolien et photovoltaique - tout en diminuant la part des sources pilotables, ici le nucleaire. Ce changement de paradigme implique de repenser la gestion des systemes energetiques. En effet, l'intermittence des renouvelables genere un besoin de flexibilite a differentes echelles de temps, de la journee a l'annee. Ne pouvant plus se reposer sur la flexibilite des moyens pilotables, cette these questionne le potentiel d'autres moyens pour y repondre: stockage d'electricite, surdimensionnement de la production et reseaux de chaleur. Face a la necessite d'une approche systeme, des modeles simples ont ete developpes pour affiner la comprehension des interdependances entre production et stockages. Les indicateurs optimises sont economiques (Euros) mais aussi environnementaux: energie grise et emission de gaz a effet de serre sur l'ensemble du cycle de vie. Les performances des systemes consideres sont celles d'aujourd'hui et leur developpement est limite par les ressources et l'espace disponibles. Sans rentrer dans le detail precis du fonctionnement de chaque technologie, cette approche physique donne les domaines de fonctionnement optimaux des differentes technologies, et les cas difficiles pour lesquels les solutions manquent encore. Dans un premier temps, le besoin en flexibilite genere pour differents taux de penetration de l'intermittence est quantifie pour plusieurs echelles de temps. Cela permet de comparer le potentiel de differentes technologies de stockage d'electricite a chacune de ces echelles pour mettre en phase production et consommation. Les resultats montrent que les temps longs - typiquement le stockage saisonnier - sont ceux qui demandent les plus gros investissements pour une faible rentabilite. Ensuite, les mecanismes de competition entre plusieurs stockages et le surdimensionnement sont analyses pour montrer dans quel cas les optimums utilisent des solutions complementaires. L'etude aborde alors le potentiel du couplage entre le reseau electrique et le reseau de chaleur comme moyen de flexibilite, notamment pour la gestion des besoins longs termes. Ce travail de these se focalise a l'echelle Francaise, bien que la methodologie soit applicable ailleurs

Files

Restricted

The record is publicly accessible, but files are restricted to users with access.

Additional details

Additional titles

Original title (English)
Analyse et modelisation des impacts du developpement des energies renouvelables intermittentes sur le systeme electrique Francais: Etude du potentiel du stockage de l'electricite, et de la complementarite avec la chaleur

Publishing Information

Imprint Pagination
200 p.
Report number
FRCEA-TH--14273

INIS

Optional Information

Notes
128 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses