Published June 7, 2022 | Version v1
Report Restricted

Nanoscale simulation of reactive transport: application to nuclear glass dissolution

Description

When nuclear glass is altered in a confined environment, a silicated and nanoporous alteration layer called 'gel' forms at the glass/solution interface, limiting the transport of reactive species and leading to a decrease in the glass alteration rate. These passivating properties may partly find an origin in a decrease of water mobility/reactivity in a nanoconfined environment. In order to better understand the origin of this passivating effect, a study coupling classical Molecular Dynamics (MD) and experiments is performed. Six different glasses with five-oxides each are simulated, displaying various B, Al and Si content, deviating from nuclear glass compositions to try establishing a global alteration model. A gel simulation method is developed, based on glass simulation followed by the removal of soluble elements (B, Na). Both the porosities and their size distribution depend on the quantity of soluble elements in the 'dry' gels. The greater the initial system destabilization, the longer the reorganization time. Moreover, tricoordinated Al are formed at the pores' surface, which is an artefact of the interatomic potentials. Two types of water are identified during the gel hydratation thanks to the use of dissociative potentials: 'pore' water inside the pores and 'reticulated' water inside the gel network. A continuous reequilibration between these two types of water is observed. The study of the diffusion inside the pores highlights a greater water mobility at the pores' center, and the presence of calcium in pore water does not impact water dynamics in a nanoconfined environment. Model glasses were synthesized and numerous experiments were conducted, in diluted (initial rate) and silica-saturated (residual rate) conditions. Results indicate the existence of a continuum between two gel formation mechanisms: either by dissolution/reprecipitation or by hydrolysis/condensation. The location between these two modes depends on the Al content in the glass, reinforcing the vitreous network: it is beneficial in the initial alteration rate regime but noxious in the residual rate regime, slowing down the reorganization of the silicate network into a passivating gel. This is not reproduced by the simulations because tricoordinated Al induce a greater reorganization of its environment. At low B content, B and Na behave differently: B is not that mobile compared to Na which is exchanged through interdiffusion with H+/H3O+. At high content, B percolation opens paths allowing for Na release, and passivation may be due to closing of these canals during gel reorganization. Isotopic tracing indicated a low pore accessibility, consistent with numerical simulations except for one glass. Water diffusion in the gel would thus not depend on the porous network topology (open vs closed porosity) but instead may be controlled by more or less favorable exchange reactions depending on the nature and position of the sites, which become slower as the gels mature. (author)

Abstract (French)

Lors de l'alteration des verres nucleaires en milieu confine, une couche d'alteration silicatee et nanoporeuse, appelee gel, se forme a l'interface verre/solution, limitant le transport des especes reactives et conduisant a la diminution de la vitesse d'alteration du verre. l'origine de ses proprietes passivantes est en partie attribuee a une diminution de la mobilite/reactivite de l'eau en milieu nanoconfine. Afin de mieux comprendre l'origine de ces proprietes passivantes, une etude couplant Dynamique Moleculaire (DM) classique et analyses experimentales est effectuee. Six verres a cinq oxydes sont simules, presentant des teneurs variables en B, Al et Si s'eloignant des compositions des verres nucleaires pour tenter d'etablir un modele global d'alteration. Une methode de simulation des gels est developpee impliquant la simulation de verres puis le retrait des elements solubles (B, Na). La porosite et la distribution de la taille des pores dans ces systemes 'secs' dependent de la quantite d'elements solubles retires. Une destabilisation initiale plus importante du systeme conduit a un temps de reorganisation plus long. On observe de plus la formation d'Al tricoordonnes en surface des pores, artefacts des potentiels interatomiques utilises. Deux types d'eau sont identifies lors de l'hydratation des gels simules grace a l'utilisation de potentiels dissociatifs: l'eau 'porale' dans les pores et l'eau 'reticulee' dans le reseau du gel. Une reequilibration continue entre ces especes se produit. l'etude de la diffusion au sein des pores montre que l'eau est plus mobile au milieu des pores et que la presence de calcium dans l'eau porale ne modifie pas la dynamique de l'eau en milieu nanoconfine. Les verres modeles ont ete synthetises et de nombreuses experiences ont ete conduites, en milieu dilue (vitesse initiale) et en milieu sature en silice (vitesse residuelle). Les resultats montrent l'existence d'un continuum entre deux modes de formation des gels: par dissolution/reprecipitation ou par hydrolyse/condensation. La position entre ces deux modes depend de la teneur en Al du verre, renforcant le reseau vitreux. l'Al est benefique en regime de vitesse initiale, mais nefaste en regime residuel car il ralentit la reorganisation du reseau silicate en gel passivant. Cet aspect n'est pas correctement reproduit par les simulations car l'Al tricoordonne implique de grandes reorganisations de son environnement. A faible teneur en B, le B et le Na se comportent de maniere differente: le B est peu mobile contrairement au Na dont le relachement se fait par interdiffusion avec les especes H+/H3O+. A teneur plus elevee, la percolation du B ouvre des chemins permettant le passage du Na, et la passivation du gel pourrait etre due a la fermeture de ces canaux lors de la reorganisation du gel. Les tracages isotopiques indiquent une porosite peu accessible, coherente avec les simulations numeriques sauf pour un verre. La diffusion de l'eau dans le gel ne dependrait alors peut-etre pas de la topologie du reseau poreux (porosite ouverte vs fermee) mais pourrait etre controlee par des reactions d'echanges plus ou moins favorables en fonction de la nature et de la position des sites, ces echanges devenant globalement plus lents avec la maturation du gel

Files

Restricted

The record is publicly accessible, but files are restricted to users with access.

Additional details

Additional titles

Original title (French)
Simulation a l'echelle nanoscopique du transport reactif: application a la dissolution des verres nucleaires

Publishing Information

Imprint Pagination
195 p.
Report number
FRCEA-TH--16225

Optional Information

Notes
251 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses