Development of computation schemes for small-sized boron-free PWR
Description
Commercial pressurized water reactors (PWR) typically rely on high electrical output power, greater than or around 1 GWe. With the emergence of newly identified uses such as power supply in remote area or heat production, small modular reactors (SMR) concepts have been designed with an electrical output power below 300 MWe. Although soluble boron is commonly used in PWR to control the reactivity, some SMR are designed without soluble boron in the primary circuit. The reactivity control in soluble boron-free (SBF) reactors relies mainly on the insertion or withdrawal of control rods. The introduction of burnable absorbers also contributes by design to the reactivity control. Soluble boron-free SMR can be justified regarding safety, economic and environmental advantages.Two-level deterministic computational schemes are generally used for PWR modelling. The first step consists in 2D detailed assembly calculations where refined energy and spatial meshes are considered to solve the neutron transport equation. In the standard computational scheme, a first depletion calculation is performed over a full range of burnup steps in an All-Rods-Out (ARO) configuration to compute isotopic concentrations. Branch calculations are then carried out at each burnup step by varying different parameters: moderator density, fuel temperature and rod insertion. The fine energy mesh cross sections are then collapsed to two-group cross sections and homogenized over the pin cell. This cross section library is then used at the core level to compute the 3D power distribution by solving the two-group diffusion equations. With SBF cores, the assumption of an ARO configuration for computing the fuel depletion can be questioned since the depletion history includes the presence of inserted control rods that modifies the neutron spectrum.The first objective of this thesis is to quantify the numerical biases introduced by the standard neutronic computational scheme in the modelling of SBF fuel assemblies, cluster and SMR core including a large quantity of burnable absorber (in the form of gadolinium oxide). The second and main objective is to develop a method able to simulate spectrum history effects over the entire core at reasonable computing cost.This work is carried out using the APOLLO3-R deterministic code. The developed method called COHLISEE is inspired from previous work found in the scientific literature about spectrum history effects. COHLISEE is a hybrid method that consists in using both microscopic depletion and spectrum history indicator in 3D diffusion core calculation. The multigroup cross section libraries are generated by merging All Rods Out (ARO) and All Rods In (ARI) depleted libraries. The method has been verified and validated on fuel assemblies and 2x2 cluster 2D calculations. Reference results have been obtained with 2D transport calculations performed with controls rods inserted following specific sequences. COHLISEE results (reactivity, power, material balance) are compared to standard schemes using either macroscopic or microscopic depletion. The V and V process shows that macroscopic standard calculations are leading to massive numerical biases on reactivity for all control rods sequences studied. With the microscopic standard scheme, numerical biases are relatively small for UO2 fuel assembly without burnable absorbers but can be comparable to macroscopic standard scheme for poisoned fuel assemblies. Core calculations performed with the COHLISEE method show a reduction of the numerical biases, especially on pin-by-pin power distributions, at a computing cost comparable to standard microscopic scheme.In order to compare the COHLISEE method to standard schemes, 3D whole-core calculations are performed for a SBF-SMR benchmark. This study evaluates the magnitude of numerical differences between COHLISEE and standard schemes. (author)
Abstract (French)
La puissance d'un reacteur a eau pressurisee (REP) industriel est generalement de l'ordre de 1000 MWe. Avec l'emergence des nouveaux marches tels que l'alimentation de sites isoles ou la production de chaleur, des concepts de petits reacteurs modulaires (small modular reactor ou SMR) sont proposes avec des puissances inferieures a 300 MWe. Certains concepts de SMR n'utilisent pas de bore soluble dans le circuit primaire, malgre son utilisation quasi-systematique dans les REP. Le controle de la reactivite de ces reacteurs repose donc principalement sur l'insertion et le retrait des grappes de controle. L'utilisation de poisons consommables a poste fixe permet egalement un controle de la reactivite a la conception et limite la quantite d'absorbants mobiles inseres dans le coeur. Un schema de calcul deterministe en deux etapes est generalement utilise pour la modelisation des REP. La premiere etape est un calcul de transport neutronique sur une geometrie 2D detaillee d'un assemblage combustible en reseau infini. Dans un schema de calcul standard, une evolution toutes grappes extraites (TGE) est realisee sur une plage de burnup. Des calculs de reprise sont effectues a chaque pas de burnup en faisant varier les parametres principaux de fonctionnement tels que la densite du moderateur, la temperature du combustible et l'insertion de la grappe de controle. Les sections efficaces multigroupes sont ensuite condensees a deux groupes et homogeneisees a l'echelle de la cellule combustible. Les librairies de sections efficaces ainsi obtenues sont utilisees a l'etape coeur pour le calcul des distributions 3D de puissance par resolution de l'equation de la diffusion a deux groupes d'energie. L'hypothese d'evolution du combustible en configuration TGE necessite d'etre remise en question au regard de l'insertion prolongee des grappes de controle pour un coeur de REP sans bore soluble, qui modifie le spectre neutronique d'evolution. Le premier objectif de ce travail de these est de quantifier les ecarts numeriques introduits par le schema de calcul neutronique standard pour la modelisation d'assemblage, de cluster et de coeur d'un REP sans bore soluble fortement empoisonne. Le second objectif est de developper une methode qui permette de simuler des effets d'historique de spectre a l'echelle d'un coeur complet de SMR sans penalite excessive sur le temps de calcul. Ce travail a ete realise avec la plateforme deterministe multi-filieres APOLLO3-R. La methode developpee, baptisee COHLISEE, est une methode hybride qui consiste a utiliser a la fois une evolution microscopique et un indicateur d'historique de spectre lors d'un calcul de diffusion. La methode est verifiee et validee grace a des calculs d'assemblages et de cluster 2x2 en 2D. Les resultats de reference sont obtenus par des calculs en transport realises avec des sequences particulieres d'insertion de grappe de controle. Les resultats de COHLISEE (reactivite, distributions de puissance, bilan matiere) sont compares a ceux obtenus par des schemas standards utilisant des modeles d'evolution macroscopique ou microscopique au niveau coeur. Le processus de verification et de validation (V et V) montre que le schema macroscopique presente des biais considerables sur la reactivite pour toutes les sequences etudiees. Les ecarts numeriques avec le schema microscopique sont relativement faibles pour un assemblage UO2 sans poisons consommables mais peuvent etre comparables au schema macroscopique en presence d'absorbants gadolinies. Les calculs de coeur realises avec la methode COHLISEE reduisent les biais numeriques, notamment sur les distributions de puissance crayon par crayon, avec un cout de calcul comparable au schema standard microscopique. Afin de comparer COHLISEE avec les schemas standards, des calculs critiques en 3D sur un coeur de benchmark de SMR sans bore soluble sont realises
Files
Additional details
Additional titles
- Original title (French)
- Developpement d'un schema de calcul neutronique pour la modelisation du pilotage des SMR (Small Modular Reactors) sans bore soluble
Publishing Information
- Imprint Pagination
- 201 p.
- Report number
- FRCEA-TH--16386
INIS
- Country of Publication
- France
- Country of Input or Organization
- France
- INIS RN
- 54123586
- Subject category
- S21: SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS; S22: GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS;
- Resource subtype / Literary indicator
- Thesis
- Descriptors DEI
- BORON; COMPUTERIZED SIMULATION; CONTROL ELEMENTS; CROSS SECTIONS; PWR TYPE REACTORS; REACTOR CORES; SMALL MODULAR REACTORS
- Descriptors DEC
- ELEMENTS; ENRICHED URANIUM REACTORS; POWER REACTORS; REACTOR COMPONENTS; REACTORS; SEMIMETALS; SIMULATION; THERMAL REACTORS; WATER COOLED REACTORS; WATER MODERATED REACTORS
Optional Information
- Notes
- 73 refs.; Available from the INIS Liaison Officer for France, see the INIS website for current contact and E-mail addresses