Published September 2006 | Version v1
Report Open

Valuing future citizens' values regarding risk

  • 1. Creighton Univ., Omaha (United States). College of Arts and Sciences/Philosophy

Description

Valuing present citizen's values regarding the risks they face is an important aspect of risk assessment and risk acceptability. Conferences like VALDOR are held for this reason. Governments like Sweden have national referendums on various risk-prone enterprises. The results of these referendums can determine the future of these programs. In the United States, when guidelines are set for determining acceptable levels of risk, the relevant federal agencies are often required to provide a comment period regarding proposed guidelines in order to ascertain the judgments, including the weights place on certain values, of individual members of society as well as stakeholder groups. After the comment period ends, the agency decides on the acceptable level of risk, taking into account the comments from present citizens. Do we also have a duty to value the not-yet-existing values of future citizens, especially if the risks created by the activities of present citizens extend into the future to citizens not yet living? If so, are there any circumstances which entitle us to de-value those not-yet-existing values. In this paper, I ground my discussion of the question of valuing future citizens' values in one of the areas of focus of the VALDOR conference: nuclear waste management and specifically the question facing the United States' program regarding an acceptable dose standard associated with the release of radioactivity into the biosphere from an underground repository. The underlying conference theme to which this discussion may be attached is community environmental justice as it applies to future citizens. I focus on the role that uncertainty plays is providing justice between present and future citizens

Files

37101592.pdf

Files (204.4 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:46a6cbeb36b3a208e4e78d4fccd006fd
204.4 kB Preview Download
Part of:
VALDOR 2006. Values in Decisions on Risk. Proceedings

Additional details

Publishing Information

ISBN
91-6318876-7
Imprint Title
VALDOR 2006. Values in Decisions on Risk. Proceedings
Imprint Pagination
616 p.
Journal Page Range
p. 565-570
Report number
NEI-SE--613

Conference

Title
VALDOR 2006. Values in Decisions on Risk
Dates
14-18 May 2006
Place
Stockholm (Sweden)

INIS

Country of Publication
Sweden
Country of Input or Organization
Sweden
INIS RN
37101592
Subject category
S12: MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE WASTES, AND NON-RADIOACTIVE WASTES FROM NUCLEAR FACILITIES;
Resource subtype / Literary indicator
Conference
Descriptors DEI
DECISION MAKING; ETHICAL ASPECTS; RADIATION DOSES; RADIOACTIVE WASTE DISPOSAL; RISK ASSESSMENT
Descriptors DEC
DOSES; MANAGEMENT; RADIOACTIVE WASTE MANAGEMENT; WASTE DISPOSAL; WASTE MANAGEMENT

Optional Information

Notes
10 refs.