[en] Numerical analyses on excitation and ionization probabilities of atoms with hyperfine structures were performed in order to compare two different excitation methods, adiabatic excitation and broadband excitation. The lifetime of the intermediate states was considered in order to investigate the effect of the absorption line broadening. The dependences of the two excitation methods on the lifetime were found to be quite different. The ionization probability by the adiabatic excitation is higher than that by the broadband excitation for identical excitation laser intensity. (author)